A strategic partnership between the Deutsch Fussball Federation (German FA) and the CFA broke ground at the second Sino-German Football Forum in Beijing last Saturday. The meeting, designed to highlight key developmental issues in Chinese and German football, covered a wide variety of topics ranging from early youth to the national team level football development. Notable speakers were Liu Jianhong (the current lead commentator for CCTV5 football matched) Dr. Walter Tokarski (President of German Sport School in Cologne) Dr. Jurgen Buschmann (Chief of German National Team Research and Development Group in Cologne), Pierre Littbarski (Assistant coach at Vfl Wolfsburg and 1990 World Cup Champion) and Lin Xiahu (Vice President of CFA). The event, hosted by Beijing University, covered two days of lectures, discussions, demonstrations, and a friendly match.
Day One: Introductions and Background Info
Following the obligatory opening ceremony and endless introductions (TIC) Dr. Walter Tokarski spoke of the “Golden Plan” in Germany. Initiated in the 1950’s the plan was supported and managed by the German government (central and local) and designed to develop the hierarchy of the German football pyramid. With clear goals and effective training methods (for players and coaches themselves) this system has produced arguably the most consistently successful national team in the world. One has to look no further than the last three world cups where Germany finished 3rd twice (2006, 2010) and 2nd (2002) thus playing the maximum number games in each tournament. No other national side can boast such consistent performances over three world cups held in three different continents.
After being informed of how and why Germany soccer is so glorious, the next speaker furthered this trend and gave a comparison of football facilities, infrastructure and investment between Germany and China. Needless to say the stark contrast of both quantity and quality of football infrastructure was evident. Littbarski then introduced the Vfl Wolfsburg training system under renowned German coach Felix Magath. Having a disciplined training regimen and setting individual goals for players is the underlying theme in Magath’s coaching style. Finishing the day’s round of speeches was Buschmann who focused on the successful achievement and business model of the German National Team. Unlike the guojiadui, the Germans make money as they play football internationally, despite the Germans investing over 200% more capital than Chinese throughout their soccer system. In summary, the lectures were quite easy to understand, even if languages were German and Chinese. The common denominator throughout all was – German football has a great model, and China has much to learn.
The afternoon featured a host of VIP’s participating in an open discussion. International administrators, professors, media representatives, referees, and other recognized individuals shared their thoughts and opinions on the challenges and realities of Chinese football. The focus hardest questions were how to transfer the success from the German soccer system into Chinese circumstances, and how to popularize the sport. However, since there was two days of preparation before the meeting, the mood was hardly heated while negligent of pressing issues. Much of the comments seemed premeditated and easy quotations for press.
Day Two: Thinking outside the Chinese box
Saturday presented another line of speeches. The first introducing the Chinese youth football system. Overall the statistics showed many amazing ‘facts’ how underdeveloped the Chinese football infrastructure remains. This included the statement that there are no amateur teams in China (I coach and play at an organized amateur Chinese football team fyi…see www.sinobalfootball.com for more info). Then came a rather interesting speech from Dr. Daniel Memmert of Cologne Sport School. First his presentation demonstrated the impressive research and analysis documenting the development of the sport in the last 50 years. Major changes shown from Fifa World Cup match data demonstrate that, on average, todays international players shoot less, yet run (distance and top speed sprints) pass, and dribble more than players 20 years ago. Later on the presentation covered innovative methods using media and games to effectively introduce ball sports to Children in a playful, engaging, and creative manner. Yet, the most interesting parts of the lecture shown were famous cognitive psychology videos of concentration and focus. . If you haven’t seen them before check them out and be amazed.
The videos suggest those heavily involved with Chinese football may not be able to see the ‘invisible gorilla’ or novelty in the room. Only an outsiders eye (ahem…like ) can grasp who and what is manipulating the shades and colors, and for what purpose. (See video for odd references, one is youtube).
Overall the press generated from such an event will garnish positive attention and hopefully support for the CFA and its long term operations. The professional and scientific models of German football shared present many administration and R&D capabilities that will no doubt boost the Chinese football development system. However, the circumstances and obstacles the Chinese football system face are not necessarily because of a lack of what the Germans are offering. Aspects neglected in the forum are the reality that the education system does not encourage or even allow most children to play recreationally and cultivate their football talents or even interest in the sport. And still few Chinese Super League, and almost no lower division, Chinese clubs are able to turn a profit from their football operations.
Nor was addressed the issue of keeping a long term national team coach who can help establish a system that leaves a legacy to build off. Recent evidence of changing coaches (often mid campaign) shows that the focus of the entire sport is mere immediate gratification. Those that fail to win are replaced, while a new incoming coach with a new system starts all over again from ground zero. Still, we are reminded that Chinese football is in its infancy, unable to even identify with its own style or brand of the game. However, even if you can teach a young dog new tricks, can you get it to stop chasing its tail? Time will tell if this union between German and Chinese Football will yield a positive impact for the sport.
- Advantage Shenhua But A Long Way To Go In Second Leg: The Chinese Football Podcast on
- Cannavaro Walks Away Proud As Quanjian Crowned Best-of-the-Rest: The Chinese Football Podcast on
- AVB Rants as SIPG Win Big: The Chinese Football Podcast on
- SIPG’s Guangzhou Evergrande smackdown, & AVB’s censoring interpreter – The Chinese Football Podcast on
- Gurning physios, the SIPG towel incident and cup frolics: The Chinese Football Podcast on