Connect with us

Chinese Super League

Pub Talk: A friendly cup final pint

With the season winding down, there’s not an awful lot to talk about besides the usual transfer rumour tedium. However the lads still make it out to the pub this week for a swift one, the second leg of the CFA cup final and the midweek friendly with New Zealand are the main topics, not an awful lot to discuss apart from that, but who can resist pub talk? Who indeed.

S: Pub Time once again. Hic. What’s news B?

B: Last night saw the national team lace up their boots for the last time in 2012, playing to a 1-1 draw against a decent New Zealand side

S: Yes, I was in attendance at Hongkou last night. I think China gave a pretty decent account of themselves, especially in the first half.

B: Oh, you made it out? I believe the announced attendance was 18,000?

S: Yeah, I was there. The attendance sounds about right, If I had to guess maybe a slightly lower.

B: Not a bad showing, especially considering the local side’s CSL attendance. Anyways, to the match, like you said, though New Zealand had some good chances, I was impressed with China in the first half, with one glaring exception.

S: Who was that?

B: Gao Lin

S: I thought he looked quite dangerous and was involved in the game a lot, he’s quite good in the air. But he wasted a golden chance apiece in both halves.

B: He was definitely involved, but my complaint about him, which has existed for many years, is that he’s good at getting himself in place, but not actually finishing.

S: Agree, but is there someone better who should be getting the chance ahead of him now? I’ve always considered Han Peng China’s best all-round striker, but he had a poor season at Luneng this year.

B: I think Yang Xu is the obvious choice, and he’s showed it at the NT level already with an impressive strike rate. Or even use Zhang Chengdong or Yu Dabao, though they may be better suited as an attacking mid. But this goes to a greater issue I have with Camacho’s managing.

S: Which is?

B: His roster shows a total lack of imagination, basically its just Evergrande’s starting XI with bits and pieces. It’s pathetic, especially when you look at all the youngsters New Zealand brought last night.

S: Yeah the NZ coach said last night he brought an under-strength squad and that his side did enough to win.

B: I don’t know, the few Kiwis that impressed me the most were some of the youngest players on the pitch. Whereas China had very little in the way of youth in the lineup.

S: Yeah. I thought Wang Dalei had a good game though, despite being at fault for NZ’s equalizer.

B: Yeah, he’s one of the very few youngsters that Camacho used last night. Wang made a few big saves and I think he’s quickly going to challenge Yang Zhi for the starting spot. He’s definitely matured over the past season.

S: Yeah I always thought he was a talented keeper, last season he had a bad time both with form and injury problems, this year he’s starting to live up to his potential. Hopefully Shenhua won’t punt him along like they seem to do with all their national team players.

B: I just wish we’d see Camacho give a chance to some more youngsters. I can’t for the life of me figure out why Zheng Zhi, Sun Xiang, and Zhao Peng still make it into the starting XI.

S: I have to agree, none of these guys are going to get any better. At least Zheng Zhi has the European experience though, that’s probably worth keeping on. Camacho has to realise though, China can’t really do significantly worse, he doesn’t have much to lose from injecting some fresh blood.

B: Even with Zheng, I don’t see why it’s worth keeping on. The focus needs to be on putting together a squad for the future, a 32-year-old Zheng isn’t helping you with that.
I am seriously left wondering if Camacho is under strict controls from the CFA or if he’s just having a laugh and playing it safe.

S: I imagine he’s leaned on from certain quarters to look favourably upon certain players. That is the Chinese way.

B: Perhaps that’s it, Zheng’s still paying for his position, LV suitcases go a long way. It just doesn’t seem like Camacho is willing to look beyond Evergrande.

S: And Evergrande are stockpiling national team players. What a curious situation.

B: Granted, almost all the Evergrande players (I think Qin Sheng is the only exception from last night’s lineup) had NT appearances before joining the team, but still, its disappointing, especially when I look back to what Gao Hongbo did.

S: In fact, in a curious parallel, The Chinese national team and Evergrande both did exactly the same thing at a critical juncture in their campaigns – fired a successful Asian manager and brought in a big-name European coach. Is that a co-incidence? That is, fired an Asian manager who had been relatively successful.

B: I believe any similarities on that front are all coincidental. Especially when Evergrande did what the CFA should have done, bring in a world class manager instead of a boob.

S: I’m not sure what to think. I think it’s not all a co-incidence. Both parties wanted big-name managers. Although you have reasonable doubts about him, Camacho managed Real and Spain, the CFA thought with that experience, he should be good enough to make a difference in China.

B: He managed Real for less than a season and while he was in charge of Spain, he didn’t exactly light the world on fire for them. I don’t want to rehash this debate, but outside of the CFA, he’s nobodies idea of a “big name”.

S: Right, I don’t think his record is really impressive either, I’m saying, this is how the CFA thought. But yeah you have a point, I think everyone would have rather seen Lippi in charge rather than Camacho, if the choice could be made.

B: I mean, there’s a connection in that you have two really rich people who don’t really know a lot about football and just wanted to bring in a “prestige” name and that’s why the changes were made. It’s the Chinese way. But I don’t think there was any collusion or any choice of timing or anything like that between Evergrande and the CFA, which is why I said its a coincidence.

S: I think we agree about this, you’ve obviously had too much beer.

B: So we talked a lot about Evergrande and a little about Gao Hongbo, what did you think of their first leg clash?

S: I thought it was a pretty decent game, carried a solid report of the leg. I think Guizhou missed their chance though really, I think Evergrande are in the driving seat. But anything could happen yet.

B: It was a good first leg (and not to pat ourselves on the back but the report was great). Obviously the result favored Evergrande, giving them a slight advantage this weekend, but it’s still an open affair. I kinda feel like we’re headed to penalties.

S: Yeah big up to Chris for the report. It could very well goto penalties, what an exciting spectacle that would be.

B: I think if you’re a Evergrande hater or a Guizhou fan, there are plenty of reasons to be optimistic, especially with the additional wear and tear on Evergrande’s NT players.

S: Yeah Guizhou definitely have a chance. But if I were a betting man, er, I would have a punt on Evergrande.

B: Only Dalian (more reason for tears) and Shandong have ever done the double (both doing it twice). I have a feeling we’ll see Evergrande do it as they always seem to find the goal they need.

S: Yeah. Credit to them for that, wouldn’t you agree, sir?

B: Certainly. Of course these two sides are going to be major players in the transfer market, with news of talks between Guizhou and Frank Lampard in the news a lot lately.

S: Yeah. Actually I have a feeling there might be some substance to that one. Famous last words!

B: I wouldn’t be surprised. Guizhou’s been involved in some rumors this past year that came to naught, but they weren’t exactly stingy with their spending. I think with the maotai money they have, and the excitement around the team, they’re going to make a big signing in the offseason.

S: Yes, plus I heard on the grapevine from a very good source that a “major European player” is coming to China in the close season. That’s not surprising of course, the real question is the identity of that individual, or indeed, individuals…

B: We’re certainly going to see more than one, but will Shenhua continue to be a buyer?

S: That’s a very good question. Anelka is apparently on his way out, which is unsurprising to everyone. It’s all down to the shareholder dispute and how it’s resolved. If I had to make a prediction, I’d say Shenhua will continue their big-spending ways and the dispute will be resolved. I just hope they realise buying three foreign forwards is pointless.

B: I think we might see continued spending with R&F and Aerbin, but I don’t know if anyone else is going to jump into the fray. Maybe we’ll see Guoan doing so, but I think it’s going to be much of the same.

S: Yeah I’d say that’s likely, we’ll see the spenders spend more and the more sensible teams spend sensibly. Unless there are some sudden changes in ownership, which isn’t outside the realm of possibility.

B: Anything is possible in Chinese football.

S: Indeed, we’ve seen it many times.

B: Time to end our pub session for another week?

S: I think so. Until the next transfer rumour!

UK trained journalist and long-time Chinese football observer Cameron Wilson has been writing about Chinese football for over a decade...

6 Comments

6 Comments

  1. Yiddo Huayi

    16/11/2012 at 17:56

    Out of curiosity, just before Gao Hongbo got ‘replaced’ he was blooding quite a few youngsters, then when Camacho came on board he reverted to the oldies.

    How many of those young uns of Gao’s have been re-instated into the NT?

    Also from the websites it looked like the average age of the NT squad was 25. That’s not an old squad dare I say. Mind you the AWs squad was 23 I think (and yes, our youngsters are prepared to run at the opposition and actually pass rather than lump it as we have done in the past).

    HOWEVER – we did miss our elderly statesman, Admiral Nelsen – who provides a lot of stability in our defence and that showed in the first half when China was running through us at will. While it is always good to see young talent coming through there needs to be a balance with experience (hopefully associated with calmness and organisation!).

    A real howler from Wang Dalei to miss the cross from the free kick, but Chris Wood had an easy nod in from an unmarked position.

    • bcheng

      18/11/2012 at 21:00

      The average age of the starting XI was 26.7, if you add in the subs who made it onto the pitch, it goes down to 26.1. I’m guessing that’s perfectly normal in international football, my complaint is that if you’re a team with nothing to play for, why not start developing your young players? Of the players Camacho used against NZ, the only Gao “youngsters” were Zhang Linpeng and Lu Peng, though Camacho has used Zheng Zheng from time to time. The three Yus (Hanchao, Dabao, and Hai) are all guys that Gao brought into the NT and have remained under Camacho, but they are hardly the “youngsters” that I think about when I think of Gao, especially because now, they are 25, 24, and 25 respectively.

      What I liked about Gao was that he was very experimental. He realized China is far from a point where a certain player is an automatic selection and so he would try a number of combinations, regularly bringing in guys in their earlier 20s or even their teens. Some of the time the choices didn’t work, but he would try things and adjust them as needed.

      Camacho has pretty much been the exact opposite, choosing established veterans, pretty much choosing the entire Evergrande team at times (including 31 year old Wu Pingfeng, giving him his first few caps), and focusing on winning these friendlies instead of building a team and letting youngsters gain experience.

      With Gao, it was daring and it was obvious he was picking the lineup. Camacho’s sides feel like they’re picked by some bureaucrat at CFA headquarters and show very little in the way of thinking.

  2. Martin Kuroczik

    17/11/2012 at 21:05

    Alright, where I sat it looked more like 8,000 spectators were in attendance but I could not see the seats underneath since we were sitting in Up in Block 12. Was it really 18,000 people?

  3. Roon

    20/11/2012 at 10:53

    …heard on the grapevine from a very good source that a “major European player” is coming to China in the close season. That’s not surprising of course, the real question is the identity of that individual, or indeed, individuals…

    Beckham?

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Shanghai Shenhua

shanghai shenhua logo 2016
Established: 1993

Ground: Hongkou Football Stadium, Hongkou District, Shanghai

Capacity: 35,000 (26,000 for football)

Honours: Chinese top-tier league champions: 1995

Chinese top-tier league runners-up: 1996, 1997, 1998, 2000, 2001, 2005, 2006, 2008

Chinese FA Cup winners: 1998

Chinese FA Cup runners up: 1995, 1997, 2015

Most recent soccer data here. The system is currently retrieving statistics from data feed.

Latest Shanghai Shenhua results

Most recent soccer data here. The system is currently retrieving statistics from data feed.

Upcoming fixtures

Most recent soccer data here. The system is currently retrieving statistics from data feed.

More in Chinese Super League